Sam Kaufman

AI and the Remodeling Industry

KPIs Without Targets Are Trivia

“Here’s our close rate.”

Okay. Is that good?

Most owners can’t answer that question. They know the number. They don’t know what the number is supposed to be. So they track it, glance at it on Monday and move on.

That’s not management. That’s trivia.

A KPI without a target is just a fact. A KPI with a target is accountability. This is part of a series on why AI is not your business model.

Fewer numbers, not more

The first mistake is tracking too much. Forty metrics on a dashboard means nobody is responsible for any of them.

Each discipline needs three to five numbers. That’s it. The ones that move profit.

Marketing - Lead volume - Cost per lead - Speed to lead - Cost per sale

Sales - Set rate (leads to appointments) - Close rate (appointments to sales) - Average sale - Gross margin sold

Production - Gross margin delivered - Margin variance (sold vs. delivered) - Cycle time - Callbacks

Finance - Net profit percentage - Overhead as a percentage of revenue - Cash on hand

Customer - Reviews and rating - Referral rate - Response time on customer messages

Leadership - Revenue per employee - Percentage of KPIs on target

Every one of those has a direct line to net profit. That’s the filter. If a number doesn’t connect to the bottom line, it doesn’t make the dashboard.

Targets come from the model

Here’s where most companies go wrong. They set targets based on what feels good, or what they hit last year, or what some guy at a conference said.

Targets come from your model. Period.

If you’ve done the math in Your Business Model Is a Math Problem, you already know what every number has to be. Net profit target sets gross profit. Gross profit sets revenue. Revenue sets jobs. Jobs set appointments at your close rate. Appointments set leads at your set rate.

That’s your close rate target. That’s your cost per lead target. Not because they’re nice round numbers. Because the model needs them to produce profit.

Now your close rate has a meaning. If it’s below what the model needs, you’re behind, and you know exactly what it’s costing you.

Leading and lagging

Net profit is a lagging number. By the time you see it, the month is over.

You need leading numbers too. Speed to lead tells you about next month’s appointments. Set rate tells you about next month’s sales. Margin sold tells you about next quarter’s margin delivered.

Watch the leading numbers weekly. Watch the lagging numbers monthly. If a leading number misses target two weeks in a row, act before it shows up in the P&L.

Every number needs an owner

A KPI nobody owns is a KPI nobody moves.

Every number on the dashboard gets one name next to it. Not a department. A person. That person reports on it every week. If it’s off target, they come with the reason and the plan.

That’s the meeting rhythm. Short, weekly, number by number. Green, keep going. Red, what’s the plan.

Where AI fits

Now here’s the payoff.

Once every KPI has a target and an owner, you finally have a way to judge AI. Every AI project should name the KPI it’s supposed to move, the current number and the target.

  • Instant lead response should move speed to lead and set rate.
  • AI proposal review should move gross margin sold.
  • Handoff summaries should move margin variance and callbacks.
  • Admin automation should move overhead percentage and revenue per employee.

Measure before. Measure at 30 days. Measure at 90. If the number moved, keep it. If it didn’t, kill it. No feelings. Just the number.

That’s how you stop AI from becoming a hobby. Tie it to a KPI, tie the KPI to a target, tie the target to the model.

AI can also run the dashboard itself. Weekly KPI reports that build automatically, flag anything off target and land in every owner’s inbox before the meeting. That alone saves most companies hours a week.

The test

Pick any number on your dashboard. Ask three questions:

  1. What’s the target?
  2. Where did that target come from?
  3. Who owns it?

If you can’t answer all three, you’re tracking trivia.

Next in the series: You Get the Behavior You Pay For, on aligning pay to the targets that matter.